When buying a brand new automotive, or perhaps a used one for that matter, individuals are usually most concerned about reliability. Given how well-liked German automobiles are nowadays, one of the questions that keep popping up time and time again revolves around the topic of the most reliable German car.
More specifically, everybody wants to know which German-made automobile is the finest choice if you’re worried about reliability and upkeep prices. Since there are a quantity of hundred different German automobile fashions from over a dozen totally different manufacturers, we can’t presumably go over every one in this article.
Instead, what we’ll do is divide every part into totally different lessons or segments if you’ll. We’ll start with small economic system vehicles and hatchbacks and work our means up to sedans and SUVs.
To accurately rate each automotive on this article I’ll be utilizing sources from various reliability businesses similar to Reliability Index and J.D. Power, in addition to fanatic boards corresponding to Piston Heads and Bimmer Forums to name but a few.
I’ll be taking into account numerous fashions from manufacturers corresponding to VW, Audi, BMW, Mercedes, and Porsche. Use this article as a loose information solely and all the time examine the situation of each automobile and its previous service historical past.
Small Economy Car
If you stop and think about it, this phase boils right down to a fight between the one two German automobiles in it: the VW Up! and the Audi A1. Yes, you could argue that the VW is a lot cheaper than the Audi and is an financial system automobile whereas the A1 is a small luxurious automotive, but that’s inappropriate.
The reality is that if you’ve received the cash and want a small daily runabout as an alternative of using your main/weekend automobile, each of these vehicles will play that part superbly. If you want a diesel you’ll have to select the A1 for the explanation that Up! doesn’t include a diesel option, so there’s that.
That being mentioned, the little Up! scores better in most reliability tests than Audi’s venerable A1. A WhatCar survey discovered the VW Up! to be an extremely dependable motor vehicle, with just 3% of all cars registered struggling any kind of issue or fault. They gave it an astonishing 99.4% reliability ranking.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
The Audi A1 remains to be an excellent different, and the one alternative if you want a small automotive that’s additionally luxurious and absolutely brimmed to the highest with options and gadgets. The Audi A1’s cabin is also on a wholly completely different level from the VW’s. Common faults with the A1 include seatbelt fraying across the edges, turbo failure, and sliding roof issues. These faults are often isolated though and aren’t widespread.
One necessary note: I didn’t mention the VW Polo because it shares lots of components with the A1, together with many of the engine choices, so points and operating prices are roughly the identical. The Polo is extra practical than the A1 and it prices much less, however it’s obviously less luxurious inside.
My pick for this class: VW Up!
Mid-Size Compact Hatchback
This is certainly one of the most highly-contested segments in the automotive sector, so I needed to do a lot of analysis to come to a conclusion concerning which is probably the most reliable German car.
Let’s start with the BMW 1-Series since it’s the plain driver’s choice. It has a great chassis and is the only rear-wheel drive on this section, nevertheless it has far too many electrical problems to win the reliability take a look at.
What’s extra, first and second-gen vehicles had a problem with the timing chain, where it may take the entire engine with it should it snap and break. Preventative maintenance can be tough because the chain sits behind the motor near the bulkhead, which means the whole engine needs to be dropped for the service.
The redesigned Mercedes A-Class turned out to be considered one of Mercedes’ hottest models thus far, however it’s not their most dependable. While the engines themselves are rock stable and just about indestructible (especially the Renault engines used on the lesser trims), every thing surrounding them is inclined to a minimum of one problem or one other.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
Certain mannequin years have been identified to leak oil due to a bad O-ring, the driveshaft can detach itself and cause lack of drive, however worst of all are points with the double-clutch transmission which may be costly to fix. Mercedes carried out quite poorly in WhatCar’s recent reliability tests, coming in twenty sixth out of 31 manufacturers.
The VW Golf and the Audi A3 are nearly the identical vehicles beneath as they share the identical chassis and the identical underpinnings. The VW is clearly the cheaper automotive with the slightly ‘worse’ interior, when it comes to materials no less than, nevertheless it provides the higher bang on your buck.
Common faults embrace DPF issues, EGR valve faults, suspension elements failure, and leaky doorways. That being stated, a second-hand Golf or A3 is all the time going to be cheaper to repair than an A-Class or a 1-Series.
My choose for this class is: VW Golf
Hot Hatchback
Once once more, I’d prefer to point out that my personal favourite from this segment is the outgoing rear-wheel-drive BMW M135i/M140i, however being a 1-Series at its core, it shares the identical points with the bottom vehicles.
The A45 AMG is an astonishing automotive, it absolutely is. It’s some of the speedy issues you could ever come throughout. It’ll demolish most supercars on a good B-road thanks to its four-wheel-drive system and over 350 horsepower, but it’s not the winner of this test. A highly-strung 2.0-liter engine will require a ton of upkeep and god-forbid something ought to fail or break as a result of it’ll value a ton of money to repair.
Once again then, it all boils all the method down to VW and Audi. I love the RS3’s unimaginable turbocharged straight-five cylinder engine and the noise it makes, however I can’t reside with how understeer-y it is. It does alright by way of reliability, far better than both the BMW or the Mercedes, however it’s outclassed by the Golf R.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
The Golf R is a sensational car. It’s one of many quickest scorching hatchbacks point to level, and it uses a smaller 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine, not the RS3’s 2.5-liter unit. The largest points with the Golf are cheap plastics in the cabin which trigger rattles, a weak clutch on manual-equipped automobiles, and soot within the exhaust pipes.
If I had to purchase a scorching hatchback purely based mostly on reliability though, I wouldn’t bother with any of those and I’d simply get a Golf GTI instead. Yes, it’s front-wheel-drive only however meaning two fewer axles and one much less diff to worry about. It’ll also be kinder on its suspension elements.
My pick for this class of essentially the most reliable German cars is: VW Golf GTI
Luxury Mid-Size Sedan
This is arguably essentially the most profitable segment for each of the producers talked about here, however all the vehicles are so completely different you surprise if they’re even competing against each other.
The BMW 3-Series is the plain alternative if you would like the final word driving machine. It steers higher than any of its competitors, it has essentially the most dynamically capable chassis, and it has the most potent engine vary of any of its German rivals.
The most dependable German car in its class it isn’t though, as it is often plagued with electrical issues and ancillary failure. Common faults embrace however are not restricted to water pump issues, thermostat failures, turbocharger malfunctions, and much more.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
The C-Class has one of many nicest rides on this phase and a gorgeous-looking inside. Cars built earlier than and together with the W204 technology had impeccable construct high quality, but issues took a flip for the more serious with the W205-gen. Issues include squeaky interior panels, rattling trim pieces, and failing sensors.
The Audi A4 is, for many individuals, the ideal on a daily basis automotive. It’s front-wheel-drive in standard trim so it’s simpler to personal and keep, the diesel examples are really frugal and have been confirmed for generations, and it has one of the nicest cabins in its segment. And but, if you go for the Quattro all-wheel-drive versions you’ll have a automobile that’s unstoppable come rain or shine.
The Audi A4 is a comparatively dependable automotive that shares most of its engines with the VW Golf, meaning it’s neigh-on bulletproof in terms of engine issues. It does like to make use of lots of oil though, and that’s also the most typical problem reported with any Audi A4 technology. Despite that, it’s still comfortably essentially the most reliable automotive amongst its peers.
My decide for this category of most dependable German cars is: Audi A4
Large Luxury Sedan
The BMW 5-Series is a big luxurious sedan that drives like a much smaller car. It actually has no business being nearly as good within the corners as it’s. Early E60-gen automobiles had some points with EGR valves and so they loved to devour suspension elements at unreasonable rates. The F10 which succeeded the E60 generation was an all-around better vehicle, returning extra MPG and reporting fewer faults.
The current G30 5-Series is arguably the best automotive the company’s ever built. It’s beautiful to take a look at, the inside is incredibly constructed, and it’s full of the newest devices and options. The ZF 8-speed box is bulletproof too.
The Mercedes E-Class has an amazing-looking interior, nevertheless it isn’t as nicely constructed as the S-Class is. Like the C-Class, it’s additionally susceptible to squeaks and rattles, and its infotainment system isn’t pretty much as good as BMW’s iDrive.
According to WhatCar’s testing, the most recent E-Class didn’t perform as well as its predecessor did. It still scored a decent 93.7% within the reliability rating, but it might have been lots better.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
Despite successful the mid-size sedan segment, Audi’s A6 performs incredibly poorly in relation to reliability, particularly in comparison with its smaller sibling, the A4. Common faults include elevated oil usage (as most VW Group cars do), timing chain issues, gearbox issues, A/C issues, a broken flywheel, failing electronics, and extra.
The most recent Audi A6 appears to fare higher in phrases of reliability, but older-gen vehicles are notoriously costly to fix.
Because of its wonderful engine lineup and the indestructible ZF gearboxes, I have to give this spherical to the BMW. Yes, it nonetheless has its own widespread faults and small foibles, however which car doesn’t?
My choose for this category of most reliable German vehicles is: BMW 5-Series
Luxury Limo
Choosing a winner in this phase feels a bit pointless because these are a variety of the most unreliable automobiles you’re ever going to come back throughout. The BMW 7-Series is probably one of the worst used vehicles you can buy. Don’t be fooled by low-cost used prices on the second-hand market. Anything that can go incorrect on an old 7-Series will. It’s not a question of if, but when.
Mercedes’ S-Class doesn’t fare a lot better than the 7-Series thoughts you. Used diesel-powered S-Class variants are slightly more dependable than their fuel counterparts, but only simply.
Being heavy and hulking, they like to put on out suspension elements rather shortly. Fixing the air suspension, should it fail, is a total nightmare and cash pit. Avoid AMG models just like the plague unless you have mountains of money you don’t mind throwing down the drain. Worst of all is the V12-engined S65 AMG.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
The Audi A8 is the least bad of the bunch in relation to reliability. A lot of the frequent points contain electrical components or ancillaries, which is a million occasions better than engine or gearbox points.
They’ve been recognized to undergo handbrake problems and sensor failures. As is the case with the opposite two, the air suspension is a major weak point and a total nightmare to fix.
My pick for this category of most reliable German automobile: is a tie between the Audi A8 and the Mercedes S-Class
Compact Crossover
BMW makes two compact-ish crossovers, so I’ll squeeze them both in the identical category even though one is barely bigger than the opposite. The BMW X1 and X3 share a lot of the identical components, so they have the identical weak factors and common issues.
The 2.0-liter diesel engines endure the same snapping timing chain issues because the four-cylinder engines found within the 1-Series and the 3-Series (it’s the identical unit), giving the X1 and the X3 a nasty popularity total. It’s an actual shame as a outcome of the automobiles are in any other case pretty reliable.
Mercedes debuted the GLA and the GLC in 2015, making them comparatively new models compared to their German counterparts. The engines are a bit crude and agricultural, but they’re alright when it comes to reliability. As with most newer Mercs, the cabins suffer from a questionable construct high quality.
They’re also vulnerable to make noises on full lock and are susceptible to ‘crabbing’. Crabbing occurs when the wheels on one axle of the automobile seem like out of alignment with the wheels on the other.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
According to WhatCar’s reliability study, the Audi Q3 is a reasonably dependable automobile. Most of the widespread complaints stem from diesel (25%), whereas simply 13% of all fuel homeowners complained about any points with the engine.
With the fuel variant, the commonest points are electrical gremlins and bodywork-related points. According to WhatCar, Audi has done quite nicely as a brand in their check, ending 20th out of 31 manufacturers.
The one I’d personally suggest, despite what you might learn on the internet, is the Porsche Macan. It shares plenty of its underpinnings with the Q5 however it’s obviously been tweaked by Porsche to make it so much sportier. According to WhatCar, the Macan is probably one of the most dependable luxurious crossovers on the market, finishing an incredible third in their study.
My decide for this class of most dependable German vehicles: is the Porsche Macan
Luxury Mid-Size SUV
Sticking true to the model, the BMW X5 is a big SUV that looks like a 4×4 off-roader. Yet, it has the dynamic capabilities of an everyday automobile. It’s outstanding how such a large automotive with such a excessive heart of gravity can behave like a sedan. But, it certainly does.
Common points depend on which X5 generation you go for. But, as a basic rule of thumb, most cars experience electrical issues and ancillary faults. Child security locks have been identified to not interact absolutely and tailgates can creak on sure mannequin years.
Issues with the EGR valve are not unprecedented. Still, it’s a common fault that may trigger the engine to chop out. Last but on no account least, wheel bolts on cars manufactured between the thirteenth of July 2018 and the 2nd of August 2018 must be checked. This is as a outcome of they gained’t have been tightened appropriately on the factory.
The Mercedes GLE is also relatively new, however solely in name. Before Mercedes’ newest naming nomenclature, it was known as the ML. The first-gen Mercedes MLwase was known to rust badly in colder climates, however they’d extremely dependable engines.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
The newest GLE is among the most reliable SUVs in accordance with WhatCar. Only 18% of all tested GLEs encountered any sort of issues, and most had been non-critical and concerned engine electrics or steering-related faults. Over two-thirds of these vehicles might be driven and taken to the workshop under their own steam.
Judging by the Audi Q5’s efficiency, one would safely assume that the Q5 is simply as reliable. But alas, that’s not the case. Early iterations of the Q5 suffered quite so much of common faults, together with heavy oil consumption, creaking or leaking panoramic sunroofs, malfunctioning cigarette lighters, boot swap failures, DRL faults, and a ton extra issues.
Once again, judging by WhatCar and their rigorous checks, I’d have to offer this win to the Cayenne, the Macan’s bigger sibling. Early fashions did suffer from some computerized gearbox points. Plus, the air suspension is prone to failure particularly because the car goes by way of the getting older course of. But even so, the Cayenne is a strong vehicle.
It’s the one I’d personally go for, even when I was shopping for second-hand. Stay away from the Turbo and Turbo S variants and also you shouldn’t encounter any major points.
My pick for this category of most reliable German car: the Mercedes GLE tied with the Porsche Cayenne
Luxury Full-Size SUV
Finally, we’ve come to the behemoths of the SUV phase. The BMW X7 is BMW’s latest flagship SUV. It’s a real seven-seater, go-anywhere and do-anything kind of automotive. As it’s so new, frequent points are hard to diagnose. But, reading the forums online I’ve come across one fault over and over again.
The sensor for the rear seats can malfunction. Thus, causing the automotive to suppose the rear seats are both jammed up or down. If it does this, you’ll get a warning on the sprint you can’t take away and the seats will sporadically not need to go up or down. A quick trip to the vendor for a model new sensor sorts out the problem. So, it’s nothing too severe or costly.
The X7 30d is your safest bet as that engine has been proven in lots of different purposes. I’d avoid the M50d if I were you because shopping for a quad-turbo 3.0-liter diesel is simply asking for bother. Yes, it’ll be remarkably fast for an SUV, however repair prices, as quickly as the warranty runs out, will be eye-watering.
Which One Is The Most Reliable German Car?
The Mercedes GLS is all-new for 2019. So, it’s hard to conclude whether or not it’ll be as reliable because the old GL was. Common faults with the GL embrace entrance suspension issues (leaks in the air suspension). And, gearbox issues (hard shifting within the decrease gears).
The Audi Q7 is probably the most popular automotive on this section, and for good purpose. Owners have reported very few frequent faults throughout the range, with the most extreme being misfiring problems, knock sensor problemsand even gas tank pressurization issues.
Early-gen Q7s had an appetite for tires. This is as a end result of they used to wear down the outer edges significantly greater than another space. In some instances, homeowners had to replace their front tires in as little as 5,000 miles. Despite that, the Q7 is well probably the most dependable automobile here, but I reckon the X7 will be the most dependable automobile of the ‘new’ technology SUVs.
My choose for this category of most dependable German automotive: the Audi Q7 tied with the BMW X7
FAQs
If you’re nonetheless curious to know more about probably the most reliable German automotive, maybe our FAQs right here might help…
Which German Car Is Most Reliable
Depending on the class of vehicle that you’re looking at, essentially the most reliable German automotive varies. For smaller cars, VW makes some of the most reliable. This includes tiny metropolis vehicles just like the VW Up! or the VW Golf (or the hotter Golf GTI). Once you step it up a notch, it’s a close battle between Mercedes, Audi, and BMW. Between sedans, the most reliable ones include the Audi A4, BMW 5-Series, Audi A8, and Mercedes S-Class. Mercedes and BMW also dominate within the crossover and SUV house, with the GLE and X7. Although, that is one spot that they should share with Porsche, with their Macan and Cayenne.
Is Porsche German
Porsche is a German brand, which was founded means again in 1931. They’re headquartered in Stuttgart, Germany, the place they were established greater than 90 years ago. In truth, its founder, Ferdinand Porsche, has a big place in the historical past of German automobiles. He had a hand in establishing Volkswagen, in addition to working alongside Mercedes again within the day for its race automotive program. Today, Porsche focuses primarily on efficiency vehicles (as they’ve always been), although they’ve branched out to making luxury automobiles in general. These embrace luxurious crossovers, sedans, and SUVs. They also have an EV now, the Taycan.
Is BMW German
BMW is certainly a German brand, and it’s one of the oldest on the earth right now. Founded again in 1916, it initially received its ground by making aircraft engines and motorcycles. To this present day, BMW remains to be headquartered in Munich, Bavaria, Germany. That’s the place they got their name, the Bayerische Motoren Werke (aka BMW), which translates to the Bavarian Engine Works company. It was a little while before BMW made its first automobile, again in 1928. Soon thereafter, BMW then stopped making airplane engines after the Second World War ended. Today, their major business is making performance and luxurious vehicles, as properly as sporting bikes.
Is Audi German
Audi is likely considered one of the most iconic German manufacturers in historical past. Although, its institution is rather confusing. Its founder, August Horch, based Audi as early as 1909. The name Audi got here from the Latin word for Listen, which is what Horch means when translated from German to English. In 1932, Audi was merged alongside 3 different German automobile manufacturers – Horch, DKW, and Wanderer. This then formed Auto Union, and that is also how Audi obtained its brand – the 4 automotive brands interlinking with each other with the 4 rings. After the Second World War ended, Volkswagen bought out Auto Union from Mercedes, which renamed it again to Audi. From the Nineteen Sixties onward, this is how we’ve come to know the model.
Is Mercedes German
Mercedes-Benz isn’t only a German brand, however it’s also one of many oldest car brands that also exist to today. Mercedes was based as early as 1883, and its founder, Karl Benz, is credited with creating the first trendy automobile as we all know it right now. The Benz-Patent Motorwagen is thought to be the first proper car, whose template still lives on in trendy cars – especially regarding its profitable use of an inner combustion engine. While most individuals recognize Mercedes as a maker of luxurious and efficiency vehicles, in actuality, they’re far more diverse. Mercedes, even right now, is likely considered one of the largest makers of business autos, like trucks, buses, and vans.
Approved Tools
These instruments have been tried and examined by our staff, they are perfect for fixing your automobile at home.
report this ad